Fly Fishing PRIME collection CDC SHUTTLECOCK HARES EAR NYMPH 12 Flies size 14
Kylebooker Fly Fishing PRIME Collection CDC Shuttlecock Hares Ear Nymph 12 Flies Size 14: A Detailed Review on Value for Money
For fly fishing enthusiasts, selecting the right flies is crucial to a successful day on the water. The Kylebooker Fly Fishing PRIME Collection CDC Shuttlecock Hares Ear Nymph 12 Flies (Size 14) has gained attention among anglers for its unique design and affordability. But does it truly offer good value for money? Let’s dive into an in-depth analysis of this product’s performance, durability, and cost-effectiveness.
1. Product Overview
This collection includes 12 hand-tied flies, featuring a blend of CDC (Cul de Canard) feathers and traditional Hare’s Ear dubbing. The Shuttlecock-style design enhances buoyancy and mimics emerging insects, making it ideal for still waters and slow-moving streams. Sized at 14, these nymphs are versatile enough to target trout, grayling, and other freshwater species.
2. Quality and Craftsmanship
One of the standout features of this set is its hand-tied craftsmanship. Each fly is meticulously constructed with:
– CDC feathers for natural movement and floatation.
– Hare’s Ear dubbing for a lifelike, buggy appearance.
– Durable thread and hooks that resist bending or rusting.
Compared to mass-produced flies, the PRIME Collection offers better consistency in tying, ensuring reliable performance. However, some users report that the CDC fibers may wear out after extended use, which is typical for delicate materials.
3. Performance on the Water
The Shuttlecock Hares Ear Nymph excels in imitating emerging mayflies and caddis pupae. Its buoyant CDC wing keeps the fly riding high in the film, while the weighted body sinks slightly, creating a realistic drift. Anglers have reported success in:
– Euro-nymphing setups.
– Dry-dropper rigs (as a trailing nymph).
– Stillwater chironomid imitations.
The 14 size is a sweet spot—large enough to attract fish but small enough to appear natural. However, in faster currents, a slightly heavier version might be needed for deeper presentation.
4. Durability and Longevity
While the flies are well-tied, CDC feathers are delicate and may degrade after multiple catches. That said, the Hare’s Ear body holds up well, and the hooks are sharp and strong. With proper care (drying after use, storing in a fly box), these flies can last a full season or more.
5. Price vs. Competitors
Priced at $15–$20 for a dozen, the Kylebooker PRIME Collection is mid-range—more affordable than premium brands like Umpqua or Orvis but slightly pricier than budget options. Given the hand-tied quality and effective design, the cost is justified for serious anglers.
6. Verdict: Is It Worth It?
✅ Pros:
– Excellent imitation of emerging insects.
– Good hook quality and durability.
– Fair price for hand-tied flies.
❌ Cons:
– CDC fibers may not last as long as synthetic materials.
– Not heavily weighted for fast/deep water.
Final Rating: 4.3/5 – A solid mid-tier option that balances cost and performance. Ideal for anglers who prioritize natural presentation over extreme durability.
Conclusion
If you’re looking for effective, well-crafted nymphs without breaking the bank, the Kylebooker PRIME Collection is a worthwhile investment. While not indestructible, its lifelike action and reliable hooks make it a high-value choice for trout and grayling enthusiasts.
Would you try this set? Share your thoughts in the comments! 🎣